Discover why Baby Reindeer lost at BAFTAs despite Emmy success, while Jessica Gunning saved the night.
Table of Contents
Did Netflix’s hottest show just lose its golden touch?
Baby Reindeer—the miniseries that captivated viewers worldwide—hit an unexpected roadblock at the 2025 BAFTA Television Awards.
After sweeping through the Emmys, Golden Globes, and other major ceremonies, the Richard Gadd creation came away with just a single win from its four nominations.
what happened to the awards juggernaut?
The once-unstoppable series found itself outshined by British productions closer to home.
Mr. Bates vs The Post Office claimed the coveted Limited Drama category, while Lennie James beat out Gadd himself for the Leading Actor trophy.
Was it just tough competition or something more?
The show’s controversial real-life connections might have played a role.
Since its April 2024 release, Baby Reindeer has faced legal challenges, including a defamation lawsuit from the woman who claims to be the real-life inspiration for Martha.
Who saved the night for Team Reindeer?
Jessica Gunning emerged as the show’s lone bright spot, taking home the Supporting Actress award for her haunting portrayal of Martha.
In her acceptance speech, she touchingly thanked Gadd for “changing her life” while reflecting on their journey together.
Could this mark a turning point for the series?
After dominating American awards shows, this stumble on home turf raises questions about whether the tide is turning for the once-untouchable Netflix hit.
What does this mean for streaming giants at traditional ceremonies?
While Shōgun claimed another win in the International category, the night largely belonged to traditional British broadcasters, with the BBC and ITV dominating many categories.
Is controversy finally catching up?
The series that dared to blur the lines between fact and fiction now faces both legal scrutiny and perhaps a cooling of critical enthusiasm—proving that even the most celebrated stories eventually face their moment of reckoning.
The truth about great TV? Sometimes the most powerful stories burn brightest before fading fastest—leaving us wondering what compelling drama will capture our collective imagination next.